Longboardsurfing.org

Method · report dated 2026-09-27

Nothing reached SOLID

29 features of offshore forcing and coarse geometry were tested on 31 breaks. None passes Holm correction and none survives every robustness check. Six size features and three wind features clear BH-FDR q < 0.06 (not < 0.05) with bootstrap CIs that exclude zero. The directional items are hypotheses to test on a larger, better-matched set, not findings.

22vs 9
longboard + ambiguous vs control breaks
main comparison
29
features tested
BH-FDR and Holm over all 29
0.054
best BH q
best Holm p 0.08
4,000
bootstrap draws per CI
Cliff's δ, Mann-Whitney p

Groups

Longboard (L, n = 16): waves widely named in mainstream English-language surf media as premier longboard or log waves. Ambiguous (A, n = 6): Rincon, Snapper/Rainbow, Raglan, Arugam Bay Main Point, Chicama and Pavones, ridden often on longboards but equally known as performance waves. Control (C, n = 9): Pipeline, Teahupo'o, Puerto Escondido, Jeffreys Bay, Cloud 9, Mundaka, Supertubos, Kirra and Cabo Blanco, chosen for fame as heavy waves. The main test uses L+A (22) against C (9). Selection is subjective and biased toward English-language media; the controls are not matched shortboard waves in moderate climates, and that matters for the size result. Ericeira/Ribamar, Doheny, Tea Tree and Huanchaco were left out as not clearly longboard waves or as grid-cell duplicates.

Take-off coordinates

Each candidate point was checked against OpenStreetMap natural=coastline ways and placed 100–600 m seaward of the coastline, by break type. Shore orientation is the normal of roughly 1 km of coastline down the line of peel (points) or centered on the peak (reefs and beaches). Twelve of 31 first-guess coordinates were on land before this step. As a check, the offshore mean wave direction combined with the shore normal predicts the correct peel direction at all 22 single-direction breaks.

Data (free sources only)

Waves
Open-Meteo marine archive, era5_ocean: hourly wave height, mean period (Tm, not Tp) and direction, 2015-01-01 to 2024-01-31, ending before the 2024-02-01 ERA5-Wave shift (Hs about 9% low, Tm about 0.5 s low after it). A full-period rerun to 2025-12-31 changed no δ by more than 0.14. Cells are 3–53 km from the take-off (median about 26 km); 31 breaks map to 28 cells (Snapper and Kirra, Sayulita and El Anclote, San Onofre and Cardiff share cells).
Swell partitions
Meteo-France MFWAM (meteofrance_wave), 2022–2025, about 8 km grid, 1–17 km from the take-off.
Wind
Open-Meteo archive, ERA5 0.25°, 10 m wind at the take-off, 2015–2025, local time.
Tide
Open-Meteo sea_level_height_msl (Meteo-France SMOC with FES tides), 2024 hourly. Mean daily range agrees with NOAA great diurnal range within 0.04 m at Santa Monica (1.66 vs 1.65), La Jolla/Cardiff (1.64 vs 1.62), Santa Barbara/Rincon (1.68 vs 1.64) and Honolulu/Waikiki (0.62 vs 0.58).
Bathymetry
GEBCO 2020 via OpenTopoData on seven transects (shore normal ±60° in 20° steps, 200 m spacing, to 19 km); slope between the 20 m and 50 m crossings, median over transects that do not cross land. GEBCO type ID from the GEBCO WMS at 1–8 km. ETOPO1 as a cross-check.
Bottom type and wave direction
Surf-guide consensus recalled from memory; web search was unavailable in the session, so these are unverified. Direction is supported by the geometry check above.

Statistics and grades

Each feature gets Cliff's δ (L+A vs C) with a 4,000-draw bootstrap CI and a Mann-Whitney p. BH-FDR and Holm corrections cover all 29 features. Robustness checks: leave-one-break-out, strict (L only vs C), ambiguous moved to control, and one break per ERA5 cell.

What held (directional)

  1. Glassy mornings. Share of 06:00–10:00 hours with wind under 2 m/s: 0.39 vs 0.15, δ +0.64 (CI +0.26 to +0.94), p 0.006, q 0.054, Holm 0.17. Leave-one-out δ +0.60 to +0.79; strict +0.71; ambiguous-as-control +0.58; tropics +0.56, outside +0.73. Not explained by latitude (ρ 0.01) or distance to the wind cell (ρ 0.07); keeps δ +0.39 after ranking out the wave ceiling. Caveat: ERA5 wind at 25 km cannot see sheltering by headlands or bays. Strongest result.
  2. Longboardable daylight hours (Hs 0.6–1.5 m and glass or light offshore): 0.31 vs 0.15, δ +0.66, q 0.054; weakens to +0.35 with ambiguous-as-control. Combines items 1 and 3.
  3. Low wave ceiling and frequent hits of the size window. Hs p90 1.61 vs 2.66 m (δ −0.58); hours above 2.5 m 0.4% vs 12%; hours at 0.6–1.5 m 81% vs 29% (δ +0.58); days with 3+ window hours 88% vs 39%; months with half their hours in the window 12 vs 3. One factor. The same signal appears in MFWAM (p90 δ −0.53, window δ +0.45). Collapses to |δ| 0.15–0.31 with ambiguous-as-control: it likely reflects the choice of controls.
  4. Year-to-year reliability of the window share. CV 0.07 vs 0.18, δ −0.70 (CI −0.94 to −0.38), the best raw p (0.003). Mostly "a high share is also a stable share"; shrinks to about −0.40 when the window level is ranked out.
  5. Clean mornings (glass or light offshore): 0.69 vs 0.49, δ +0.50, q 0.10; weakens to +0.29 with ambiguous-as-control.
  6. Size after a crude refraction factor: δ −0.48, q 0.11, but ambiguous-as-control removes it (+0.06). Treat as killed.

What did not hold (kills list)

  1. An obliquity "sweet spot": longboard obliquities run from 1° (Cardiff) to 174° (Imsouane) with no band; δ(|obliquity|) +0.14; hours at 20–60° δ −0.20; regional obliquity +0.03.
  2. Consistency mattering more than size: hourly Hs CV δ −0.16.
  3. A slope threshold: GEBCO 20–50 m slope δ −0.22 (CI −0.70 to +0.29). J-Bay 0.003, Supertubos 0.004 and Kirra 0.004 sit on gentle offshore slopes.
  4. An Iribarren (breaker-type) separation: longboard 0.08, control 0.14, δ −0.15; at the offshore slope almost every break reads as "spilling".
  5. Longer period: Tm δ −0.07; swell Tm +0.15; hours at 12 s or more +0.23.
  6. A narrower directional window: circular SD δ +0.03.
  7. Tide range and relative tide range: δ +0.16 and +0.33, CIs through zero.
  8. Swell share of energy: δ +0.32, CI through zero; little spread.
  9. Seasonality and afternoon onshore wind: δ −0.40 and −0.33, CIs through zero.
  10. Coast turn at the take-off: δ +0.27; wrap-around geometry is common among controls too.
  11. Geometry-filtered size: removed by ambiguous-as-control.

Full test table (29 features, sorted by p)

Group medians are longboard (L+A, n = 22) and control (n = 9). δ is Cliff's delta: +1 means every longboard break is higher than every control. Copied from the report of 2026-09-27.

FeatureLongboard medianControl medianCliff δ95% CIp (MWU)q (BH)p (Holm)LOO δ rangeStrict δAmbiguous→control δOne-per-cell δGrade
window_frac_interannual_cv
year-to-year variation of the 0.6–1.5 m window share
0.0700.175-0.70-0.94 to -0.380.0030.0540.08-0.80 to -0.66-0.67-0.33-0.76DIRECTIONAL
frac_daylight_window_and_clean
daylight hours with Hs 0.6–1.5 m and glass or light offshore
0.3120.152+0.66+0.29 to +0.950.0050.0540.14+0.62 to +0.76+0.65+0.35DIRECTIONAL
morning_glass_frac
glassy mornings (06–10 h, wind under 2 m/s)
0.3860.152+0.64+0.26 to +0.940.0060.0540.16+0.60 to +0.79+0.71+0.58DIRECTIONAL
frac_days_3h_in_window
days with at least 3 window hours
0.8840.390+0.60+0.23 to +0.900.0100.0540.27+0.55 to +0.70+0.53+0.21+0.66DIRECTIONAL
hs_p90
90th-percentile Hs (wave ceiling)
1.6102.660-0.58-0.88 to -0.210.0130.0540.33-0.68 to -0.53-0.56-0.31-0.63DIRECTIONAL
frac_hs_gt_2.5
hours above 2.5 m
0.0040.119-0.58-0.88 to -0.210.0130.0540.33-0.67 to -0.53-0.53-0.17-0.62DIRECTIONAL
frac_hs_0.6_1.5
hours at 0.6–1.5 m
0.8110.292+0.58+0.19 to +0.880.0130.0540.33+0.53 to +0.68+0.50+0.17+0.63DIRECTIONAL
months_window_ge_50pct
months with half their hours in the window
12.0003.000+0.54+0.14 to +0.850.0160.0560.36+0.49 to +0.66+0.48+0.15+0.61DIRECTIONAL
hs_median
median Hs
1.1701.680-0.56-0.88 to -0.160.0180.0560.37-0.66 to -0.50-0.52-0.23-0.61DIRECTIONAL
morning_clean_frac
clean mornings (glass or light offshore)
0.6890.491+0.49+0.02 to +0.870.0350.1010.70+0.43 to +0.68+0.50+0.29DIRECTIONAL
hs_geomfiltered_median
Hs after a crude refraction factor
0.5120.911-0.48-0.82 to -0.080.0410.1080.78-0.57 to -0.43-0.33+0.06DIRECTIONAL
season_ratio_hs
seasonality of Hs
1.3961.600-0.40-0.79 to +0.040.0900.2161.00-0.51 to -0.34-0.47-0.46-0.32KILLED
afternoon_onshore_gt5_frac
afternoon onshore wind over 5 m/s
0.0230.044-0.33-0.70 to +0.110.1570.3391.00-0.41 to -0.25-0.36-0.19KILLED
relative_tide_range
tide range relative to wave height
1.7681.210+0.33-0.13 to +0.750.1640.3391.00+0.24 to +0.47+0.33+0.18KILLED
swell_energy_frac_median
swell share of wave energy
0.9980.979+0.32-0.13 to +0.710.1770.3431.00+0.23 to +0.44+0.40+0.33+0.24KILLED
frac_geomfiltered_0.6_1.5
window share after refraction factor
0.3220.473-0.29-0.67 to +0.110.2150.3891.00-0.35 to -0.24-0.08+0.24KILLED
coast_turn_deg
coast turn at the take-off
17.00014.000+0.27-0.16 to +0.670.2480.4231.00+0.18 to +0.35+0.22+0.03KILLED
frac_tswell_ge_12
hours with swell period 12 s or more
0.0990.053+0.23-0.23 to +0.670.3270.5271.00+0.15 to +0.38+0.28+0.29+0.16KILLED
gebco_slope_20_50
seabed slope, 20–50 m
0.0070.019-0.22-0.70 to +0.290.3610.5501.00-0.34 to -0.12-0.16+0.04KILLED
frac_hours_obl_20_60
hours at 20–60° obliquity
0.1310.209-0.20-0.64 to +0.250.3960.5741.00-0.34 to -0.11-0.03+0.25KILLED
hs_cv
hour-to-hour variability of Hs
0.2980.320-0.16-0.60 to +0.310.5140.6461.00-0.29 to -0.07-0.12-0.05-0.12KILLED
tide_mean_daily_range_m
mean daily tide range
1.5071.361+0.16-0.32 to +0.600.5140.6461.00+0.06 to +0.29+0.17+0.07KILLED
iribarren_tm
Iribarren (surf-similarity) number
0.0750.136-0.15-0.63 to +0.380.5280.6461.00-0.27 to -0.06-0.07+0.09KILLED
tswell_median
swell mean period
9.3258.350+0.15-0.32 to +0.610.5420.6461.00+0.07 to +0.28+0.17+0.13+0.06KILLED
obliquity_abs
obliquity of mean swell to the shore
106.31665.142+0.14-0.32 to +0.590.5570.6461.00+0.05 to +0.25+0.03-0.17KILLED
tm_median
mean wave period
8.9508.950-0.07-0.51 to +0.380.7940.8851.00-0.18 to +0.02-0.03+0.04-0.16KILLED
obliquity_regional_abs
obliquity to the regional coast
71.17970.142+0.03-0.42 to +0.480.9130.9311.00-0.09 to +0.11-0.07-0.17KILLED
obliquity_hourly_iqr
spread of hourly obliquity
30.50032.000-0.03-0.44 to +0.390.9310.9311.00-0.10 to +0.09+0.01+0.08KILLED
swell_dir_circstd
swell direction spread
24.44821.232+0.03-0.40 to +0.450.9310.9311.00-0.07 to +0.15+0.21+0.35-0.04KILLED

Method checks and limits

Data: CSV · JSON · table, map and charts · per-break pages.